McLouth or McCutchen

Okay, who is the better CF, Nate McLouth or Andrew McCutchen.
Before the Pirates traded Nate McLouth in June, his stats where:
.256 AVG 9 HR 34 RBI 7 SB, and since his trade to the Braves his stats have been just about the same with 9 HR and 34 RBI and a .259 AVG, with 12 SB.
After McLouth was traded, Andrew McCutchen was called up from AAA since then McCutchen has had, .283 AVG 12 HR 54 RBI 18 SB.

So, who do you think is better?
I say Andrew McCutchen.